If you’re anything like me, there’s nothing quite like the comfort of a soft, warm pretzel. Golden on the outside, fluffy in the middle, lightly salted, and ideally dipped in something melty and indulgent.

The only problem? Most frozen soft pretzels don’t live up to that image. They come out tough, bland, or dry. I’d pretty much given up on frozen pretzels, until I found Plum Creek Foods.

This post is my honest, detailed review of Plum Creek’s frozen soft pretzels, and why I think they’re the best frozen soft pretzels you can buy online right now.

About Plum Creek Foods

Plum Creek is a family-owned company based in Pennsylvania, the birthplace of soft pretzel culture in the U.S. Their roots are deep in the Pennsylvania Dutch baking tradition, and you can taste that authenticity in every bite.

Unlike mass-market brands, they’re not trying to make a factory-line snack. They’re committed to making a real, bakery-quality pretzel that just happens to be frozen for convenience.

Everything they sell is made with simple, recognizable ingredients: flour, water, butter, brown sugar, yeast, salt, and baking soda. That’s it. No preservatives. No junk. Just real food, the way a soft pretzel should be.

What Makes Plum Creek Pretzels So Good?

Plum Creek’s pretzels stand out for three big reasons:

1. They’re hand-twisted.

Each pretzel is individually shaped by hand. That gives them a real, rustic appearance and more importantly, a perfect chewy texture in every bite.

2. They’re baked and flash-frozen at peak freshness.

These pretzels come to you already baked and buttered. After baking, they’re flash-frozen, so you’re locking in that perfect “fresh out of the oven” moment.

3. Butter waterfall finish.

They don’t just lightly brush butter on like most brands. They use a literal butter waterfall that coats each pretzel after baking. You can taste the difference.

Product Variety: Something for Everyone

Here’s what you’ll find in their store:

Original Salted Soft Pretzels – the classic, buttery soft, lightly salted pretzel
Cinnamon Sugar Soft Pretzels – warm, sweet, dessert-like, great for kids and coffee pairings
Pretzel Nuggets – perfect for game day or sharing
12-Pack Variety Box – mix and match of their best-sellers

Every product is made in the same way: no preservatives, no weird ingredients, and real butter.

Taste Test: The Best Frozen Soft Pretzels I’ve Ever Had

I’ve tried Auntie Anne’s frozen pretzels. I’ve tried SuperPretzel. I’ve even tried some fancy food subscription boxes. Nothing came close.

Plum Creek’s frozen soft pretzels have a unique combo of crisp crust and soft center. The outside bakes to a perfect golden brown, while the inside stays fluffy. And that butter? It hits the perfect savory-salty balance without feeling greasy. I’ve baked them in a toaster oven, an air fryer, and even microwaved one in a pinch. Every method worked.

They don’t dry out. They don’t get rubbery. And they smell amazing when they’re reheating.

Bonus: They go with everything. Sharp mustard. Cream cheese. Chocolate sauce. Even just plain. They’re that good.

Buying Experience and Delivery

Ordering online was simple. You can order directly from Plum Creek Foods’ website, and they ship frozen pretzels straight to your door with insulation and dry ice.

They arrive frozen solid, and you can toss them straight into your freezer until you’re ready to eat. Instructions are clear, and each pretzel is individually wrapped for convenience. You can pull out one at a time or bake the whole batch.

FAQs: Buying Frozen Soft Pretzels Online

Will they arrive fresh?

Yes. The pretzels are flash-frozen and shipped with dry ice. Mine were still rock solid when they arrived.

Are they already baked or do I need to cook them?

They’re fully baked, buttered, and frozen. You just reheat them, no baking from scratch required.

Do they come with salt or toppings?

The salted ones come pre-salted. The cinnamon sugar pretzels come fully coated. No extra work needed.

Can I bake just one or two at a time?

Definitely. Each pretzel is individually wrapped, so you can make as many or as few as you want.

How long do they last in the freezer?

Plum Creek recommends enjoying them within 6 months, but they lasted perfectly fine in my freezer for 3+ months without losing quality.

Are they gluten-free?

Currently, no. These are traditional pretzels made with wheat flour.

How do they compare to other brands price-wise?

They’re a little more premium, but you’re getting real bakery-quality flavor. I’d rather pay a few extra dollars for something I genuinely enjoy eating.

Are they good for events or gifts?

Absolutely. I’ve served them at game nights and movie nights. They’re always a hit. They also make great food gifts: unique, nostalgic, and easy to enjoy.

Customer Reviews Say It All

Here are just a few of the rave reviews I found online:

“These are the BEST frozen soft pretzels!!!!! We get them all the time and I always buy extra to give to family and friends.” – Missy P.
“Buttery, soft pretzel dough baked to perfection with just a touch of subtle sweetness. You can’t have just one!” – Jenessa F.

From what I’ve seen, most customers are repeat buyers, which tells you everything you need to know.

Final Verdict: Worth It

After years of disappointing frozen pretzels, Plum Creek Foods frozen soft pretzels has completely changed the game. They’ve managed to do something really rare: combine convenience with true, bakery-level quality.

Whether you’re just craving a great snack or looking for something special to serve guests, these pretzels deliver every time.